New film focusses on the fishing communities and why they matter
A new film commissioned by Lloyd’s Register Foundation highlights why commitment to fishing safety matters by bringing stories of three very different communities.
This page is approximately a 5 minute read
When a vessel is loaded, it sits lower in the water. The distance between the waterline and the deck edge becomes smaller. In naval architecture, that distance is called freeboard. For fishers, it can offer a simple warning about how much stability their boat still has, and how safely it can operate in changing conditions.
Vessel instability remains one of the most serious risks at sea, especially for small-scale fishers operating boats under 15 metres in length. These vessels are often exposed to challenging sea conditions, heavy gear, variable loads and changing weather. Many are too small to be covered by the larger-vessel stability requirements, leaving skippers with fewer pieces of information about the safe operating limits of their boats.
The Wolfson Unit, based at the University of Southampton, has spent more than 50 years working on vessel performance prediction, model scale testing and stability assessment. Its work is often applied in real-world settings, including accident investigations, where technical evidence is used to understand what happened and how future incidents might be prevented.
Through a small grant from Lloyd’s Register Foundation, the Wolfson Unit was able to strengthen and validate the Wolfson Stability Method, a practical approach designed to help small vessel operators understand when their boats may be at risk.
Matteo Scarponi, Vessel Stability and Safety Lead at the Wolfson Unit, explains that there are two “flavours” of the method. One applies to vessels where stability has been calculated in detail. The other is for vessels with little or no formal stability information, often because they are too small to be required to meet conventional stability standards.
For those vessels, the challenge is still the same.
“The skippers of small fishing vessels need simple, practical stability guidance to operate their boats safely,” he says. “They need to know at all times the safe operating limits of their vessels, so they can run their fishing operations within those limits and mitigate the risk of capsizing.”
The simplest version of the Wolfson Method is based on a traffic light system. If the waterline is low and the vessel has enough freeboard, the boat is in the green zone and is considered reasonably safe to operate. If the waterline rises into the amber zone, for example by lifting a heavy net over the side, the residual freeboard reduces, and the skipper needs to be mindful of the sea state. If the vessel is in the red zone, it may be in danger and could capsize even in relatively low seas.
The power of the method lies in making that engineering principle visible. Rather than asking fishers to interpret complex calculations, the Wolfson Method uses a freeboard mark placed on the side of the vessel. If the mark is fully visible, the vessel is in a safer operating condition. If the mark is partly immersed, the skipper needs to consider the sea state and operating conditions. If the mark is fully underwater, the vessel is in danger.
“The reason why the Wolfson Method is useful in real operating conditions is that it doesn’t cost the fishers anything,” Matteo says. “It doesn’t involve the input of a naval architect or any knowledge of stability beyond a bit of paint.”
“The vast majority of small fishing boats are not safe or unsafe in absolute terms,” Matteo says. “They are safe or unsafe in relation to the sea state in which they operate and to their level of loading.”
That is why the method can support practical decisions. If a vessel enters the amber zone during a lift in a high sea state, the skipper can respond by reducing the load. The guidance does not simply label a boat as safe or unsafe. It helps people understand the conditions within which it can operate more safely.
Lloyd’s Register Foundation’s small grant enabled the Wolfson Unit to test and strengthen the evidence behind that approach. The team reviewed more than 270 marine accident investigation reports from around the world, including reports from maritime safety authorities and accident investigation bodies. They analysed the findings, expanded their casualty database, and plotted new data linking probable wave height at capsize with likely vessel stability at the time of each incident.
The results were encouraging. The evidence collected indicated that all of the recorded capsize incidents fell within the unsafe zone predicted by the original formulation of the Wolfson Method.
“No capsized vessel was predicted to be safe by the Wolfson Method in its assumed operating conditions in terms of stability and wave height,” he says.
For Matteo, the grant was essential.
“Because we are a commercial consultancy, we need to fund our own applied research work,” he says. “This work wouldn’t have happened without Lloyd’s Register Foundation's contribution. Simple as that.”
The impact has moved beyond the research itself. The Wolfson Method has been captured in marine safety policy and formally recommended for field use. In the UK, it has been embedded in guidance for fishing vessels under 15 metres, with skippers required to carry a stability notice showing limiting significant wave heights against each zone. The freeboard mark itself is recommended rather than mandatory, but it gives operators a simple way to connect that notice to their own vessel.
The work has also informed international guidance. The Wolfson Unit contributed to the Food and Agriculture Organization’s guidelines for the seaworthiness and safety inspection of small fishing vessels.
Accident reports can show what went wrong. Engineering analysis can explain why. But safety improves when that knowledge is translated into tools people can understand and apply before an accident happens.
For small-scale fishers, the Wolfson Stability Method offers exactly that: a simple visual way to read the relationship between their boat, their load and the sea around them.
A mark on the side of a vessel cannot remove every risk, but it can help a skipper to see when conditions are becoming unsafe, and make informed decisions.
The skippers of small fishing vessels need simple, practical stability guidance to operate their boats safely. They need to know at all times the safe operating limits of their vessels, so they can run their fishing operations within those limits and mitigate the risk of capsizing.
Matteo Scarponi Vessel Stability and Safety Lead at the Wolfson Unit