With Foundation funding, we were able to conduct extensive community and stakeholder engagement to gauge how stability and risk are considered and mitigated. Our partners, Beckett Rankine, provided knowledge and expertise, including consultation with international museums. We also engaged a consultant to conduct vessel visits across the UK, resulting in nine registered UK static floating vessels being surveyed during the project.
Our research found that, in some vessels, significant internal machinery had been removed below the waterline, though only one had undergone major changes to the superstructure (involving the addition of new floors above the weather deck). These modifications have potentially large impacts on vessel stability.
‘During conversion, all items of machinery and weapons systems were removed to allow these spaces to be opened up and repurposed.’ (Anonymous vessel case study published in Stability Guidance)
Location and function determined other potential risks. For example, vessels moored amongst busy traffic were at greater risk of being struck by other craft, and ships open to the public have greater health and safety requirements. Vessels that had to travel to undergo maintenance were also vulnerable to damage and loss on route.
‘The main risks have been identified as the hull being hit by debris.’ (Anonymous vessel case study published in Stability Guidance)
We discovered that whilst most vessel custodians had considered the stability of the vessel, including conducting some form of stability assessment, this was not always consistent, and the level of knowledge varied significantly. Most did have an active stability booklet (a requirement for operational vessels) but previous stability tests were often unclear or incomplete. For larger organisations, ensuring policy and procedures were disseminated and understood by staff and volunteers was also a challenge.
The complex nature of historic vessels and the lack of legislative clarity make managing the safety of static vessels extremely difficult. With this project, we aimed to support vessel custodians in caring for their craft and all those on board.